
I received an email yesterday from a woman whose son is an alcoholic and who has been struggling alongside her boy and his illness. I recall talking to the young man last summer over the phone, who had planned on getting into the old treatment center I went to. He was unsure of this proposition, and my gut instinct told me that he wasn’t ready, that he was going to just get his mother off of his back, that he felt he could probably manage it all on his own.
I wish I had been wrong.
This poor kid ended up relapsing the day he left, and it went downhill from there. I had been in constant contact with this despairing woman (aren’t all family and friends of alcoholics despairing? That word was invented for them, methinks). I explained what her son was most likely going through and described alcoholism and it’s nefarious hooks that dig deep into our minds, body and spirit. She was briefly buoyed, but cautious. And then I didn’t hear from her for many months – until last night. Her son had spiralled even further down – living on the street, getting arrested, jumping from shelter to shelter, and had health concerns. He eventually cracked and asked for help. He returned to the treatment center and has done well since. She is now broke and needs to move because of this hardship, but her son is healthy and sober.
I bring this up to illustrate something – that I never would have met this woman nor been able to offer what I could if I wasn’t “out” (recovered alcoholic) with some of my friends. I have close friends, old friends, who clearly know that I am an alcoholic and have been in treatment and continue to work a recovery program. These few friends were at my one year medallion. They understand a bit of my journey and of alcoholism. It was one of these friends who introduced me to the distressed woman and son. Being open about my path yielded something wonderful – a connection to someone else who was suffering – someone I could reach out to. Someone to help. Like someone helped me at some point.

I recall once leaving a meeting, with two people walking behind me out of the door, discussing anonymity. The young woman was concerned about people at work finding out about her being an alcoholic. The man, who I know does great service work in the community, stopped and asked her point blank “What’s the downside of people knowing?”. She paused, unable to respond. I too found myself lost in thought. What was the downside of others knowing? And that line has stuck with me for the last year or so. It was something that reared it’s head up now and then as I gently stirred around the idea of being more out there, of letting others in on my “other” life. It’s a question that still dogs me, that swirls around the eddies of my conscious, that licks the edge of my decision or non-decision to break my anonymity.
There has been some discussion of anonymity on the blogs and twitter lately. Much of it stemmed from the release of a documentary called “The Anonymous People” which encourages those in recovery to speak out, to have a voice…and a face. I haven’t seen it yet, so I can’t opine about it. But what it has done is revisit my idea of anonymity, the current social environment, and my place in it – or not. This slowly trickling back stream in the recesses of my mind has lately started to push and rush a little bit more in the last six months. No particular reason why, but I have been feeling this low level rumbling about where I am in the prism of recovery – am I the light, the reflector or the rainbow? Am I all or none of these? And how does my coming out or not coming out change things? Or is this yet another incident of this alcoholic over thinking things?
Tough call.

For me, anonymity touches three aspects, each with their own questions and challenges:
1) Personal – While I am open to my family and friends, I am still private in my work life and with casual friends / neighbours regarding my alcoholism. The question of my not drinking has come up at work before and I have answered honestly, but without mentioning being an alcoholic. The “What’s the downside of people knowing?” really plays a part here. What would be the issue if I were to expose myself to peers and subordinates? What fears coarse through my mind and spirit when I think of this? Silent mocking? Shame? Judgement? Whispers in quiet corners? Me being YouTube-d, someone trying to find some embarrassing episode? I am not sure, but those have crossed my field of vision. And if that did happen, is that a bad thing?
I can’t help but think that much wouldn’t happen. That most people wouldn’t care. That most people might be gently shocked, but then again, not really be concerned. That most likely, many of these folks probably know someone that is in the grips of the grape or struggling. But what compels me to move out of my protective shell is for that last thought – that I might be of service to someone. Like that woman with her son. That perhaps I can be a voice for someone, or just be around for the reason of someone to talk to. That maybe I was meant to do more than just go to meetings or typing a few things here or being sober. Or not.

2) Online – Once it’s out there, it’s out there. That’s one of the dangerous and sharp edges of the internet. Ask any Facebook user who has tried to delete their online persona or account. Anyone who has Googled themselves and no doubt had run into something they typed in years ago, or found a picture of themselves from some ancient company newsletter, or had some mention of them deeply implanted in an archaic document of some kind. So the decision to be out there is not to be taken lightly. Now, there are many of us in the sobersphere who maintain anonymity, and for valid personal reasons. Some do not want work staff to find them. Or others have criminal and legal issues that they don’t want trumpeted. Some fear ridicule. Others feel it’s no one’s business but their own. Everyone has their reason for staying anonymous, and that is highly respected and observed in our circles.
On the other hand, there are many here who clearly feel safe in this community and are out there – face, name, workplace, etc. Many of these bloggers are not concerned much with others stumbling upon them. In fact, many are proud to be out there, and wish to show the “who” behind the Gravatar and hope that they can attract others whose voice may be quiet, or stilted. They realize almost everyone in their own circles of life are already on board and care not if one or two others fall onto their blog.
I am not concerned about someone perhaps tripping over this blog, or what I have to say here. I don’t mention names, generally, and I don’t publish personal facts. I rarely post pictures of my family (or they are very old ones) and I don’t give mention of other personal details of my private life. That is why I keep it recovery focused – the rest of the stuff is immaterial. But what it does come down to is the next area that sobriety and breaking anonymity crosses.

3) The Traditions of AA – This is where some of the difficulties come in for me. And this is also where there is a lot of gauntlet throwing down in slight challenge of these. For those who don’t know, the Traditions, as they are known in the program, are 12 guidelines, if you wish, that help to keep AA, on a whole, intact. They are there to ensure the stability and growth of AA. They help steer us away from publicity, donations, leadership issues, etc. As they joke about in the rooms, the 12 Steps help us from committing suicide, and the 12 Traditions help us from committing homicide (you have to be there, stale cup of coffee in hand, believe me). And embedded in those traditions are the basics of anonymity. The internet was far from coming to fruition when they came up with the traditions, but since it’s inception, AA does have some “official” stands on anonymity and being online.
I am not going to get into the Traditions, as that can go on for some time, but what I will say is that it’s okay to break anonymity at group level, which means at a group, I can give you my full name, phone number, etc. and not worry about it. It’s when I get out in the real world, and in any context, that I cannot be a mouthpiece for AA. I can talk about it privately, one on one, though. (This is where some see this as secretive, but it’s all meant for the good of the group as a whole). But here’s where I see things a bit differently. To me, this sobersphere, is like a group. Anyone who isn’t interested in sobriety or recover most likely won’t be interested in this blog or the ones on my blogroll…unless they were concerned about their own drinking or the drinking of someone they know. We all know each other out here, for the most part. I feel like I am part of a family. A wonderful, inclusive, accepting and loving family. And for that reason, I feel that anonymity isn’t truly broken. Or is that me rationalizing?

So what’s the verdict after all this navel gazing and star searching?
Not sure.
The greatest challenge comes from within. And the simple question is this – is this ego / pride talking, or is this an authentic desire to open up, spread wings, stay truer to myself and be open for others if they need help? Can I be comfortable as a member of a group that stresses anonymity and yet be out there? My bro of bro’s Marius (from Trudging Through The Fire) had some great advice and thoughts on this a while back, and challenges some of the more traditional thoughts generally thought of regarding the program and anonymity. (I know, Marius challenging the status quo? I was shocked too) I have had time to chew on what he’s said, and see that after some consideration, I am in alignment with his point of view. I think service, on a higher plane, is where I am directed. I have spoken about signs from the Creator before in this space, and I have always tried to do the next indicated thing. I have tried to be in tune with that little voice that likes to tell me the right thing to do. And so it’s really about being in alignment with His will, not mine.
But there is still something that nags at me.
I am not sure what it is. There seems to be something blocking me from coming out outright. From jumping out of the birthday cake with a sash and a smile. From taking the big leap. I am not sure if it’s fear, or just being uncomfortable. Or just that finality. Or something that I am not meant to do now. Who knows. What I can say is that I have had no compunction with anyone else being so open about their recovery and being an alcoholic. In fact, I love it. I know for many out there, it’s not a big deal and it wasn’t a difficult choice. I do wish to be there soon and not worry about any downsides, if there are any. I do wish to be of maximum service to others and show that we’re not a bunch of homeless people slugging back hand sanitizer (ok, some of us are, but you know what I mean). That we have a face, that we’re like others, that we are others, that we’re the coaches, teachers, workers, parents, children, etc. that you see every day. That we are all different, and yet the same deep down.
I will find my answer. I know I will. I will find out where my voice is needed, and where my heart belongs. Where my shoulders need to be opened up for a sobbing, shaking head to land on. Where my arms need to open up embrace someone who thinks death as a choice. Where I can plant my feet and catch someone who is on the rebound and ready to give up and whither away.
In the meantime, I smile inside when I hear others talk about their conquests at the bars, when they talk about having to taper off, when I overhear rumours of so-and-so being a problem drinker, when the direction of a conversation turns to the bottle. I know that if someone needs some help, I will be there. My hand will always be there, outstretched and ready to grab them and tell them that it’s okay. You’re not alone. Right now, I am there, you can feel my breath, but I am anonymous. Receding into the light, reflecting, hoping to see rainbow whenever I gaze upon you, hoping to see you be well.
Be well.
Remaining anonymous has its advantages and its downside. You can still help those who are in need without blowing your anonymity, and maybe broaden your horizons, get out of the AA box (which I feel you do). AA can give you some special perspectives on life, some good tools in recognizing problem situations and overcoming the challenges, yet folks don’t need to know that you conquered that specific mountain, what they need is a light in the darkness. You have the potential to guide folks to that light, and that can never be hidden for long. I think you hear a calling, please don’t ignore it.+++
Paul, I’m sure the answer of what God’s will is for you will be answered in its own sweet time. For now, I think you are doing what you should be doing — you touch people who struggle with alcoholism even in your anonymity. Of course, I speak only for myself but I’m guessing there are many of us that don’t know who you are but you are a guiding light in the darkness. –Fern
I think you are extremely helpful and generous with helping others whether or not you break anonymity. Maybe you could bring it up at an AA meeting and see what people say? I know that I personally never stumbled upon a sober blog until the day that I decided I needed help. I am hesitant to name my full name on my blog because I am not sure I will be able to be as honest if I do, but my need for anonymity is already less than it initially was. It’s a conundrum. Best of luck working it all out. Peace! Jen
I wrote a long comment – WordPress swallowed it… grrr…
Whatever – here is some guidance… http://www.alcoholics-anonymous.org.uk/download/1/Library/Documents/Web%20Site/Social%20Networking%20Sites%20Anonymity.pdf
I blew it as I was out on the web before I knew it – like you I considered it a group, not press, film etc. I still don’t but AA as a whole disagrees with me, I have to respect that as best I can now.
I think of my alcoholism the same way I think of my sexual preference or anything else that is deeply personal – it’s my business and with whom I choose to share it is my business as well.
One of the biggest issues I had with AA was the concept of anonymity. To me, it felt like hiding which felt like shame. So FOR me, it didn’t work. But again, that was purely a personal decision. I would never OUT anyone who didn’t want to be there – everyone has their own reasons.
Great post and discussion Paul. Thank you.
Sherry
Thanks for this Paul…
I love the 11th tradition because it makes me feel safe in the rooms. Or made me….now I don’t care. But when I came in I sure did. When I came in full of shame and self-loathing and not understanding this and feeling so different from everyone/…thank god there was no one there to out me.
Now i happily out myself, which is my prerogative. I am seeing the Anonymous people tomorrow night, a showing put together by an online friend, full of other online friends, bloggers and strangers…tho I imagine the strangers are only because I haven’t yet met them.
I love the message of this movie, of the whole recovery movement it represents….the de-stigmatizing of addiction. The teaching…people need to understand that this is a disease like any other, and it KILLS people. Looking with compassion and help rather than ostracizing and judgement is the only way to really make a difference.
That is part of the solution that I want to be involved in.
No spokespeople for AA, I accept and understand that, am grateful for it. I out myself as being in a 12 step program..a fine line but acceptable, I think. One on one I talk about AA, which is the whole plan, right? One drunk talking to another? But in the bigger picture, until the world at large starts looking at this disease differently, people will continue to die.
I’ll report back what i thought of the movie, and thanks for the discussion…it’s an important one.
I’m open about my road to sobriety and blog with my real name. I don’t, however, post links to my blog on my personal Facebook page. I’m not ashamed of anything but my “friends” aren’t my target audience and Facebook isn’t the right medium for what I write about. Anyone who is more than an acquaintance knows I’m an alcoholic but I carefully choose what I share in person or on my blog because not everyone has earned the right to know the details. It’s a fine line to walk sometimes. In my early days of sobriety, I gravitated toward people who were open about their recovery because I was looking to see my face in theirs. I think everyone has the right to do their work in private with the protection of anonymity. If they choose to go “public”, that’s ok too.
The people at work know i’m recovering in AA because they were all aware of my suicide attempt and so i wanted them to know i was getting better.
About anonymity in general, i was kind of surprised when i learned that Roger Ebert received a lot of flack when he came out as sober and in AA. i though, “WTF, if the guy wants people to know, so be it. Hell, it might even influence someone else to give it a shot.”
Just a couple days ago, however, i saw the documentary “Bill W.” and learned that Time magazine offered Bill W. the cover as Man of the Year and, after a lot of thought, he turned them down. He understood it could be good advertising for AA, but he also didn’t want AA to become a place where people got into an ego race. i was able to see that maybe the reason for anonymity in AA was not to protect the person, but the organization.
So, no answers, but i’m glad you asked the question!
My reply is equivalent to a one ton truck that I’ve manged to bring to the size of the period at the end of this sentence.
Anonymity is personal, but if you’re going to name an exact organization, any organization, that has a tradition of anonymity it is best to honor that tradition. I am of the non-anonymous type of alcoholic. Period.
I struggled so much with this when I wrote my book (published). When I finally found my solution I found so much peace in not feeling shame over who I was.
Just because you’re an alcoholic doesn’t mean you’re anonymous.
Love this post, brought up a lot for me. I barely scratched my reply.
xox
Paul, your writing is outstanding. I have to go through your posts twice just to check if I got everything the first time. The second time round is always the best one because you are such a beautiful soul and it shows in your writing. Thank you for being a wonderful recovering alcoholic. You had to go through your struggles for us, members of the sobersphere, to read your amazing material. Much love to you, dear Paul. Keep strutting your impeccable writing in these blogosphere. I am grateful for you. 🙂
Hi Paul! You know I love this topic and I have written about it several times myself. For me in the beginning anonymity was very important, i don’t think I would have stepped a foot in the rooms if I didn’t feel somewhat safe. And I truly understand the importance of it and the whole idea of attraction rather than promotion. But for me today I would like to be able to say, my name is Maggie Shores and I am an alcoholic and I am a member of _ _ 12 step program which saved my life! But I can’t do that in a public forum. This is what I am told by my district GSR. If you don’t use your real name you can call the fellowship by it’s name, if you are using your real name you should refer to it as other. For me this is a personal choice, it is to have a face as a recovering alcoholic and be more of service, I didn’t know any people in recovery before, now I have 150+ friends on FB that are all in recovery, strangely enough only 26 liked my Sober Courage FB page!? I find that alarming – the shame associated with alcoholism and/or addictions is still so huge! And the general lack of understanding amongst the public is also overwhelming. Well, anyway, I can go forever, but thank you for bringing it up, it link its a personal choice for sure. And you touch many propel with your words weather you’re anonymous or not! Sending many hugs! But it also keeps me more accountable in my sobriety.
Sorry, looks like spell/ grammar check has failed me lOl! Thanks again Paul, I am going to read the links now, get some more insight! 🙂
Paul,
As you know, I have never been to an AA meeting, and although I am familiar with the philosophy of AA, I don’t really know it fully.
Being open with my identity has never really been an issue for me, and I have never asked myself why that is. I think maybe that is the sign of when you are ready: it’s like, if you have to ask if you are an alcoholic, you probably are. And if you have to ask why you should relinquish your anonymity, then you are probably not ready to do so.
All in good time. Or maybe never. In the end, it comes down to you, since it’s your choice. You don’t ‘owe’ it to the world to live out loud; it’s something that you may, however, decide that you owe yourself 😉
Your post was quite thought provoking and well written. Paul, this ^ comment reminded me of something researcher Brené Brown said — something I really resonated with:
Also, I resonated with your comment regarding the Internet — that once it’s out there, it’s out there. That can feel quite daunting. I completely understand. I’ve only recently put my picture out there. Very recently, and I’ve been active on the internet since the mid 90’s.
Love the last image and its faceted symbolism. One of my hobbies is gemology. I am especially smitten by diamonds, but not for the traditional reasons. Diamonds (the hardest natural material known to man. It spends millions of years in the dark, under tremendous heat and pressure — waiting to be unearthed, faceted and polished so that it’s brilliance, fire, and scintillation can be admired in the light.
The image also reminded me of Pink Floyd’s album cover “Dark Side of the Moon”. A win, win. 🙂
Victoria
Hi Paul,
I’ve been away from the computer for a week or so, came back and read this… all I am thinking is: “Oh Shit!!!!!!!”
Actually, the word in my head is even more crass, I have the mouth/mind of a truck driver in my “real” life.
Okay, so I’m going to say something that will come as no surprise to you at all, since you read my blog: I have given little to no thought on this subject. I can back up this fact with reams of posts that do the exact opposite of what everyone is saying above.
I’ve kind of thought about the traditions with regard to me personally, but I guess I just never viewed myself, or even my blog, as a mouthpiece for AA (am I even allowed to write that last sentence?). For me, I am just blogging about my experiences in my personal recovery, and AA happens to be a part of it… my intent is not to promote AA in any way, it’s just to talk about a very important component of my journey to recovery. Maybe I am underselling my importance, but who gives a fig if I am a member of AA, except me? I don’t express opinions on the 12-step program in and of itself, I am speaking of the impact it had on my life….
Or at least that was what I thought, before I read this post. Now I am afraid I’ve got to turn in my membership card, since I’ve apparently broken the most sacred of traditions.
I need to say it again: Oh Shit. I guess the best I can do, at this point, is move forward with this new information, and be more careful about the way I word things on my blog. If an amends needs to be made, I guess the light bulb will go off sooner or later…
As always, Paul, you’ve given me food for thought!
Josie
I know this is an old post but the bit about helping the mother of an alcoholic made me read on. I’ve read a lot since but I think despairing was a word you used for family’s affected by this disease.
I do despair at times, wish I could share my pain with others.
We also have to remain anonymous to protect ourselves and our alcoholic.
I have shared with close friends and colleagues, only people I believe I can trust, when I do it seems they all know someone who suffers.
I think its more the stigma of the disease that causes problems.
I believe if we all spoke out more it wouldn’t be such a hidden disease. I’m not proud or disappointed with my sons sufferings, I wish I could share more, I know when I do I get something back.
I find it sad how you guys share and help each other so much, but there must be 4 family members for every alcoholic? Yet I struggle to find support from others.
If we could speak more openly it would help everyone so much.
I have learnt to say the words “my son is an alcoholic” without being embarrassed. Its a disease he has just like any other disease. Its the others that don’t understand that have the problem. But at the same time, I understand for him, I have to choose carefully who I say those words too.
I’ve enjoyed reading your thoughts on this, and everything I read helps me understand a little more.
Thank you from an anonymous mum.